top of page

Why Your McKinney Homeowners Insurance Soared & How to Fight Back!

Aug 7
3 min read

Hey neighbors! Brandon Scribner here, your trusted top realtor in McKinney, and I’m hearing a lot of chatter lately from homeowners across Texas, especially right here in our vibrant community. The question on everyone’s mind seems to be: 'Brandon, why did my Texas homeowners insurance premium jump so much this year, and can I do anything about it?' It’s a fantastic question, and one I completely understand. It feels like every year, the cost of just *owning* a home seems to creep up, and insurance is often a major culprit.


Let’s dive into why this is happening. First off, Texas, and particularly the Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex including McKinney, has faced some pretty significant weather events recently. Think about the severe hailstorms, the unexpected freezes, and the increasing frequency of strong winds. Each of these events leads to a surge in claims, and when insurance companies pay out more, they inevitably raise premiums to cover those costs and maintain their solvency. It’s a tough reality: higher claims volume directly impacts what we pay.


Beyond the weather, we’re also seeing the ripple effects of broader economic trends. Inflation has pushed up the cost of everything, from building materials to skilled labor. If your roof needs replacing after a storm, the cost of shingles and the crew to install them is significantly higher than it was a few years ago. This increased cost of repairs means that when an insurance company does have to pay out, that payout is larger, contributing to higher premiums for everyone. Supply chain issues, though easing, also played a role in material costs.


Another factor is the cost of reinsurance. This is essentially insurance for insurance companies. When they face higher risks in a volatile market like Texas, their reinsurance costs go up, and those costs are then passed down to us, the homeowners. Some insurance carriers have even reduced their presence or pulled out of the Texas market entirely, which reduces competition and can further drive up prices. As a top realtor in McKinney, I see this impact on clients looking to buy or sell, as these rising costs can affect affordability and overall property value perception. My expertise in real estate investing and listings strategies always factors in these market realities.


So, what can you actually do about it? Plenty! Don’t just accept the renewal notice. My first piece of advice is always to shop around. Don’t be afraid to get quotes from multiple providers. What one company considers high risk, another might view differently, or they might simply have better rates for your specific property. You might be surprised by the savings.


Next, consider your deductible. A higher deductible means you’ll pay more out-of-pocket if you file a claim, but it almost always translates to a lower monthly premium. Just make sure you’re comfortable with the amount you’d have to pay if disaster strikes. You could also explore bundling your home and auto insurance policies with the same carrier. Many companies offer significant discounts for this.


It’s also worth proactively improving your home’s resilience and safety. Things like installing smart home security systems, smoke detectors, or even impact-resistant roofing can sometimes qualify you for discounts. Ask your agent about specific discounts they offer – you might be missing out on savings for things like being a non-smoker, having a good credit score, or even just being a long-term customer. I often advise clients, especially first-time home buyers, to consider these long-term cost-saving measures as part of their overall homeownership strategy.


Finally, review your policy annually with your agent. Ensure your coverage limits are appropriate for your home’s current value and rebuilding costs, but avoid over-insuring. If you’ve made significant improvements, update your policy; if your home’s market value has slightly dipped, your coverage might need adjusting too. As a Pricing Strategy Advisor, I can tell you that understanding your home’s true value, not just market price, is key to smart insurance decisions.


Navigating the complexities of homeownership costs, including insurance, can be daunting. Whether you’re considering buying your first home, looking into Home Selling Services, or just trying to understand the McKinney real estate market better, I’m here to help. My name is Brandon Scribner, and I’m passionate about empowering homeowners with knowledge. Don’t hesitate to reach out for a Free Consultation to discuss your real estate needs or any questions you have about our local market. Let’s make sure you’re getting the best value and protection for your most important asset.

bottom of page